Short answer: we found 2 crypto tax firms with a Indianapolis-area presence, listed below with their sources. Licenses are not yet verified, so confirm on CPAverify before hiring.
Firms in the Indianapolis area
Edgewater CPA Group
7216 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN; offers crypto tax preparation (firm site)
License unverifiedWebsiteCrypto Taxes Plus Accounting LLC
7460 Waterfront Dr, Suite 115, Indianapolis, IN (Yellow Pages directory listing)
License unverifiedWebsite
National / remote firms
Chainwise CPA
Site says it helps clients "across the country"
Mac Tax CPA
Summ partner list says services are offered in all 50 US states
Bitcounts
Site title: "Crypto Tax and Accounting Services in the US"; works remotely
Indiana tax note
Per the Tax Foundation's 2025 state income tax table, Indiana has a flat-rate individual income tax. Federal crypto reporting (Form 8949, Schedule D) applies everywhere. See the Form 8949 guide.
See all of Indiana, all cities, or the directory. Doing it yourself? Compare crypto tax software.
FAQ
Do I need a crypto CPA in New York City?
Not necessarily. Many crypto tax firms work remotely. Ask whether they prepare New York returns and check their license on CPAverify.